Samuel Sheinbein (July 25, 1980 - February 23, 2014) is an American-Israeli punishable killer. On September 16, 1997, Sheinbein, a 17-year-old senior in John F. Kennedy High School in Montgomery County, Maryland, and Aaron Benjamin Needle, former classmate of Jewish School Day Charles E. Smith, murdered Alfredo "Freddy" Enrique Tello, Jr.. They then cut and burn dead bodies in Aspen Hill, Maryland. Sheinbein fled to Israel, where he qualified for citizenship; Israeli law at that time banned the extradition of citizens.
The case stresses US-Israeli ties and encourages an overhaul of Israel's extradition policy, which now calls for defendants who seek to avoid extradition to also show "settlement relations" to Israel. The Washington Post writes that it became "a tug of war involving the war in Congress, the State Department and Justice and the echelons of Israel's political and judicial standpoint".
Sheinbein was sentenced to 24 years in jail by an Israeli court in 1999. In 2014, he was killed in a shoot-out with Israeli police forces in Rimonim Prison after he shot and injured six officers and one other prisoner with a gun smuggled into prison.
Video Samuel Sheinbein
Murder
​​â € <â €
At the age of 17, Sheinbein told a friend that he was offering $ 5,000 for someone to kill his crush girlfriend and $ 1,000 for someone to lure his rival into the vehicle. He's looking for someone to kill as an exercise for the intended target, according to Montgomery County, Maryland Deputy State Attorney John McCarthy.
Around the same time Sheinbein plans to kill his rival, Needle and Tello get acquainted. The Needle was introduced to his classmates in Montgomery County, and a friend from Tello, Hannah Choi.
In September 1997, Needle had been involved in a fight where Tello had punched the Needle in front of Choi, whom Jarol had a crush on. Choi tells the police that the Needle looks shy and immediately calls his friend, Sam. According to McCarthy, this event caused Needle to give Sheinbein a victim of his practice.
Tello Murder
Sheinbein created a prosecutor called Recipe for Murder . On a sheet of notebook paper, Sheinbein writes "'Zap, pepper, metal restraints, rainsuits... X-Acto hobby knife, plastic bag' and other items." He also "registered the Dujitsu 2000 knife and has a check mark next to 'recommended by Consumer Reports ' ". A piece of paper also lists the size of 14 shoes (according to McCarthy, both Sheinbein and Needle wearing size 10 shoes) and have written, "If they do not fit, you must liberate", references to the famous line of Johnnie Cochran in Experiments O.Ã, J. Simpson.
Authorities believe that the killings were planned by Sheinbein and Needle. Sheinbein and Needle allegedly paralyzed Tello with a stun gun, and then strangled and stabbed Tello, eventually beating him to death with a sawed rifle. The autopsy report concluded that the cause of the victim's death was "a combination of blunt to head injury, cuts in the neck and chest, and ligature strangulation". Both stored Tello's body in Sheinbein's garage, where they chopped the victim's legs and burned the body so that Tello could not be identified as a victim. He is set to dump a corpse in an empty house for sale that was previously owned by his classmate. Sheinbein told her classmates that she wanted to use an empty residence to be with a girl in private. Authorities believe that Sheinbein and Needle transferred the bodies to their dwelling house in the garbage bag behind the Needle's Honda. Both then transported their mutilation tools in a wheelbarrow to an empty house.
On September 19, 1997, a realtor was preparing a vacant home for the show, and detected a strong odor coming from the garage. Realtor finds Tello's body wrapped in garbage bags. The corpse was so charred and mutilated that it was originally believed to be a deer carcass. The broker called the Montgomery County Police Department and the officer quickly responded to the residence. Researchers determine the contents of garbage bags are the remains of humans and decided it as a murder. Police found a Makita electric saw used to cut victims at the scene.
Investigation
Montgomery County researchers were initially unable to determine the identity of the victim. They started interviewing the neighbors who reported seeing the suspects. Using police canine teeth, authorities found traces of blood leading from a body scene to Sheinbein's garage.
Subsequent investigations led the authorities to decide Sheinbein as a suspect, and based on physical evidence and eyewitnesses, Needle was determined to become a second suspect. Warrants for the arrest of Sheinbein, for first-degree murder, and the Needle, for first-degree murder, conspiracy to commit murder, and to become an accessory for killings after the event, were issued shortly thereafter.
On September 22, 1997, Freddy Tello was reported missing by his mother. The police investigation of the missing persons report revealed that Tello had told his friends that he would meet them at the Plaza del Mercado shopping center in Silver Spring along with Needle and Sheinbein, but never appeared. Tello's dental records are used by researchers to identify victims. According to police reports, the suspects fled to New York City. The needle was arrested on September 23, 1997, but he committed suicide in April 1998 two days before the jury selection for the trial by hanging himself with a bed sheet.
Maps Samuel Sheinbein
Israel
Flights to Israel
Sheinbein avoided the arrest by the Maryland police and fled to Israel with the help of his father, Sol Sheinbein, a lawyer with dual US-Israeli citizenship. Sol allegedly carried Samuel's passport, bought a plane ticket to Tel Aviv, and drove him to John F. Kennedy International Airport to escape from the United States.
As soon as Sheinbein was in Israel, his brother Robert flew to Israel and met him in his hotel room, bringing him a bottle of first wine and a prostitute. On September 25, 1997, he survived an overdose of sleeping and wine pills in what was considered a suicide attempt. The police found a clear suicide note to his family in his hotel room, and Sheinbein was placed in a mental hospital. Sheinbein was arrested, and the US authorities were informed of his presence in Israel. In an effort to avoid extradition, Sheinbein claimed and accepted Israeli citizenship as the son of an Israeli citizen through his father, who was born in the Mandatory Palestine and emigrated from Israel at the age of six.
Extradition contest
The US Department of Justice filed a request for extradition to Israel, and US Secretary of State Madeleine Albright pressed for "maximum cooperation". Israeli Attorney General Elyakim Rubinstein opened the extradition proceedings against Sheinbein. The protracted legal battle in Israeli courts came when Sheinbein fought in extradition. The Sheinbein family hired former Justice Minister David Libai to serve on his defense team. This has caused great tension in US-Israeli relations and the anger of the Latin-American community. Congress threatened to withhold aid to Israel. Extradition sessions began in the Jerusalem District Court, led by Judge Moshe Ravid. In February 1998, Ravid offered a compromise in which Sheinbein would return voluntarily to the United States for trial, and if proven, could return to Israel to serve a prison term. He accepted the idea, but Maryland prosecutors refused it. In September 1998, Ravid ruled that Sheinbein could be extradited because he had no meaningful relationship with the State of Israel, using a US passport, and never living in Israel, so not enough citizens deserve protection under Israeli law.
The district court's decision was filed with the Israeli Supreme Court. In February 1999, five Supreme Court judges blocked Sheinbein's extradition in 3-2. This cited a 1978 law prohibiting the extradition of Israelis. While acknowledging that Israel had signed an agreement with the United States that allowed the extradition of citizens in 1963, he ruled that the 1978 law was preferred, and the lack of Sheinbein's relationship with Israel did not negate his citizenship claims. Concern is expressed over the possibility that this decision could turn Israel into a refuge for criminals. In writing his different opinion, Judge Aharon Barak, President of the Israeli Supreme Court, wrote about this possibility. The court's majority opinion, written by Judge Theodor Or, states the position that the law prohibits the extradition of Sheinbein, and the decision of the district court implies varying degrees of Israeli citizenship. Regardless of this, Or writes that it would be ideal if Sheinbein was tried in the United States: "One can wonder if there is any justification for protecting someone from extradition when the person is not a resident and has no relationship with Israel. should be put on trial for the crimes they committed in the country that is the center of their lives. "In a final attempt to get him extradited, Attorney General Elyakim Rubinstein petitioned for a larger panel of judges to re-examine the case. Supreme Court Deputy Chief Justice Shlomo Levin rejected the request.
Conviction and prisononment
Following the decision, Israeli prosecutors began preparing to try him for murder in the Israeli judicial system, and a Tel Aviv state prosecutor had been assigned at a time when the Supreme Court rejected Rubinstein's request to reconsider his decision. On March 22, 1999, State Prosecutor Hadassah Naor charged Sheinbein for murder with a view to killing in the Tel Aviv District Court. The charge is equivalent to a first-degree murder charge in the United States.
In August 1999, Sheinbein accepted a plea bargain with the prosecutor, and in September he confessed to killing Tello. In October, a panel of three judges at the Tel Aviv District Court sentenced him to 24 years in prison, with a requirement for four years of leave and parole after 16 years. It was reportedly the harshest punishment ever imposed in Israel for crimes committed by minors; before, no small ones were punished for longer than 20 years. This claim has been disputed. There is anger in Israel and the United States over this case. According to The New York Times, throughout the litigation proceedings of Sheinbein's bargaining bargain, prosecutors, judges, and even defense lawyers pointed to "apparently deep hatred" for Sheinbein, the case, and the extradition law, which at the time had changed. Judge Uri Goren, president of the panel, stated that "we are dealing with a defendant imposing himself on the Israeli judicial system," noting that Sheinbein has clearly manipulated laws that have been designed to prevent the Jews from being handed over to the anti-Semitism regime.. Montgomery County State Attorney Doug Gansler expressed his opinion that the sentence was too mild, stating "seen through the lens of the Israeli court, we agree that this 24-year sentence is a severe punishment.... But this is an American crime demanding American Justice." Even after Sheinbein's conviction, the state of Maryland retained its arrest warrant, and the United States issued an Interpol warrant, meaning that Sheinbein faced charges in the United States if he ever returned, and faced extradition to the United States if he had traveled to Interpol anywhere, regardless of whether he serves in Israel.
Sheinbein was imprisoned in a juvenile detention center until she was 18 years old, after which she was transferred to Ayalon Prison, a maximum security prison at Ramla. Later, he was transferred to Rimonim Prison, a maximum security prison at Even Yehuda, near Netanya. He finally qualified for weekend leave, and was given 96 such leave during his detention. In prison, Sheinbein worked in a wood shop and took a university course, eventually earning a degree in computer. He generally shows good behavior in prison. Months before his death, a prison spokesman described him as "a good prisoner". However, according to his lawyer, Orit Hayoun, he never received psychological counseling.
On December 13, 2012, a shiv was found in the Sheinbein cell. At that time, Sheinbein lives in a section where inmates have access to each other's cells. At the hearing of the March 2013 incident, he claimed that other inmates had planted him there, demanding that DNA samples of the weapons be tested and the recording of security cameras from the aisle outside his cell be reviewed. Both requests were rejected, but it was decided that the incident could not be used against him in a parole hearing. However, his leave was temporarily suspended.
Consequences
Israeli extradition law
Anger occurred in both countries after the Israeli Supreme Court ruling in February 1999. The Knesset then issued two laws that overhauled Israel's extradition policy in 1999 and 2001. The first bill, which had been previously filed and unrelated to the Sheinbein affair, stipulates that a citizens must have "settlement connections" to Israel to avoid extradition. The second allows Israelis to be extradited "on the assurance that, if proven, the citizens of Israel will be allowed to serve in Israel". Israel and the United States also signed the protocol on 6 July 2005, providing "reciprocal extradicts of persons accused or convicted of offenses, including attempts or conspiracy to commit offenses, punishable by law in both Parties by deprivation of liberty for a period of one year or with more severe penalties ".
Legal analysts speculate that "If Sheinbein's affair happens today [in 2014], not residing in Israel at the time of his offense, he may be extradited" to the United States.
Family
After Samuel fled to Israel, his parents, Sol and Victoria, moved to Israel, where Sol found a job as a patent law consultant. Shortly after Samuel's arrest, Sol Sheinbein and his son Robert, who were also present in Israel, were arrested by Israeli police for impeding their investigations and passports confiscated, but released shortly afterwards. The sisters of Sheinbein, Robert and Nathalie, later changed their name to Shein. Robert eventually settled permanently in Israel, where he married and had two children, while his sister Nathalie remained in the US.
Sol Sheinbein was charged with obstruction of justice in the United States. He is wanted for an arrest warrant for blocking or blocking police investigations, but because his crime is a minor crime, he can not be extradited. In 2002, he was dismissed as a lawyer in Maryland by the Maryland Court of Appeals, and in 2004, he was dismissed as a lawyer in Washington, D.C., by the Columbia District Court of Appeals. In 2004, the US Patent and Trademark Office initiated a disciplinary process against it, and in the following year revoked its patent license, which Sheinbein did not succeed.
Aftermath and death
Gun incident
On February 6, 2014, Sheinbein received a leave of absence from jail. His previous offspring had been suspended but recovered after he challenged the rejection in court. He went on to the town of Ramla, where he tried to steal a gun from a man he met online and arranged a meeting with to buy a shotgun. On the way to the ammunition store in the car, Sheinbein runs away from the seller with a gun. The seller catches and holds him until the police catch him. Sheinbein was arrested and returned to prison. He was locked up in his cell over the weekend. An indictment was filed against him for the incident, and the Israeli Prison Service made the decision to transfer it to another facility.
Standoff and death
On February 23, 2014, Sheinbein called his lawyer Orit Hayoun, thanked him and said good-bye to him, and that he would soon hear about her. Fearing that he would commit suicide, he called the prison authorities and the county attorney's office urging them to take action, but his worries were dismissed. About half an hour later, when transferred to a different prison cell, Sheinbein asked the bathroom to stop. He pulled out a gun, and shot three guards, seriously wounding two of them, before barricading himself in the bathroom. A deadlock ensued, in which the authorities tried to negotiate with him. After an hour, Sheinbein shoots police and guards around the room, and they shoot back, wounding him seriously. Despite efforts to resuscitate her, Sheinbein died shortly thereafter. Six officials and one inmate were injured by Sheinbein. The shooting took place one year before Sheinbein would be eligible to apply for parole.
The Israeli Prison Service began to investigate how Sheinbein obtained the weapon, which is believed to be smuggled into prison. Police traced the weapon to a central Israeli citizen whose pistol was stolen a year earlier. It was reported "the first known case in Israel of an inmate firing a shot inside a safe compound". A writer for Tablet Magazine mentions the fact that Sheinbein was able to acquire the latest "weapon from some large IPS screws".
In popular culture
"Back", an episode of Law & amp; Order from 2000, based on this case.
References
Source of the article : Wikipedia
0 Comments